---
name: project-three-path-bcd-2026-05-22
description: "2026-05-22 morning. 3 path 並行 — Paper 154 OpenEvolve smoke-run (scaffold 4 test PASS) + Paper 26 v2 TurboQuant Phase 1 baseline (qwen2.5:3b avg 10.9 tok/s) + Paper 156 v0.0 OUTLINE 起草 (WWD 三層 + 9 原則 体系化, publish gate 4.5)."
metadata: 
  node_type: memory
  type: project
  originSessionId: 40f20b17-e9be-489a-8df9-12b7300a1112
---

# Three path B+C+D 完了 (2026-05-22 morning)

★★★★ 朝 session で 3 path 並行実行完遂. 全 path で **publish gate を明示維持** (no-rush principle 順守). v0.1 promotion なし — どれも v0.0 stage in honest record.

## ★ B. Paper 154 OpenEvolve scaffold → smoke-run ✅

**Deliverable**: `external/openevolve-rei/smoke-run-2026-05-22.md`

**4 tests PASS**:
1. YAML config valid (random_seed/max_iterations/llm/database/evaluator/prompt/logging 7 keys) ✅
2. Python AST parse 3 files (beta_lean4_zero_sorry / gamma_dfumt8 / circle_packing_26) ✅
3. circle_packing_26.py standalone run: n=26 r=0.416667 density=14.180800 ✅
4. gamma_dfumt8 evaluator on circle example: ZERO dominant (9 hits) + score 0.0154 + OpenEvolve-compatible dict 返却 ✅

**Honest scope**:
- これは scaffold-level validation のみ
- 全 OpenEvolve 100-iteration loop = user-gated install (`pip install -e ".[dev]"` from codelion/openevolve) 未実施
- 真の v0.1 publish gate = **OpenEvolve 経由で実 evolved Lean 4 proof 生成** = 未達

**Pattern matrix self-audit**: 6 軸全 clean / guarded.

## ★ C. Paper 26 v2 TurboQuant Phase 1 baseline ✅

**Deliverables**:
- Raw JSON: `data/baseline-qwen25-3b-2026-05-22.json` (5,501 bytes, 10 records + aggregate)
- Findings: `data/turboquant-phase1-findings-2026-05-22.md`

**Headline numbers (qwen2.5:3b on i7-6700 CPU only)**:
- avg tokens/sec: **10.888**
- median tokens/sec: **10.795**
- avg wall-clock: 7,978 ms
- avg response length: 259.1 chars
- n=10 prompts

**Per-prompt range**: 9.6-12.2 tok/s (output-length driven variance, longer responses → slightly lower tok/s).

**Honest scope**:
- 単一 model のみ (3B Q4_K_M) — cross-model baseline 未取得 (Goedel-Prover-V2:8b / DeepSeek-Prover-V2:7B / bfs-prover も pulled だが本 turn 未測定)
- n=10 = statistical bare minimum, n=30+ 推奨
- TurboQuant-quantized variant 比較は **未** (`ollama pull iliafed/nemotron-quant` user-gated, +disk)
- VRAM 測定なし (CPU-only run)
- quality は response-length proxy のみ (semantic 正解性検証なし)

**Paper 26 v2 v0.1 publish gate status**:
- Phase 1 baseline ✅ (本 turn 完了)
- Phase 1 TurboQuant 比較 ⏸ user-gated
- Phase 2 SEED_KERNEL 統合 ⏸ pending
- Phase 3 RotorQuant 比較 ⏸ pending
- Phase 4 Tang silicon embedding ⏸ long-horizon

★ 重要: 単一 baseline では不足. **少なくとも Phase 1 (baseline) + Phase 1 (TurboQuant 比較) numerical contrast** が v0.1 promotion 最低条件.

## ★ D. Paper 156 v0.0 OUTLINE 起草 ✅

**Deliverable**: `papers/paper-156-three-layer-lawsuit-prevention-DRAFT.md`

**Title (working)**: "Three-Layer Open Public Datacenter with Lawsuit-Prevention Architecture and Catuṣkoṭi-Inspired Octuple Voting"

**Title alternatives 4 件** (decide at v0.1): legal-frame / technical-frame / architecture-frame / Japanese-frame.

**Co-authorship**: Fujimoto + Rei + Claude Opus 4.7 (three-party per OUKC charter v1.0) + chat-Claude **design-input via 藤本さん proxy** (§3 9 原則 four-quarter origin + §4 食べログ判例 framing) 明示記載.

**Structure (9 §)**:
1. Introduction (individual-operator aggregator dilemma)
2. Background — D-FUMT₈ as expression framework
3. Architecture — three layers (L1/L2/L3 + D-FUMT₈ mapping + L3 unreplicable moat)
4. Lawsuit-prevention — 9 principles (chat-Claude 4 + Rei-AIOS 5) + 食べログ判例 lesson + 6/6 risk mitigation matrix + honest non-claims
5. Catuṣkoṭi-inspired 8-value voting (核心 contribution) + worked-example finance ballot
6. Implementation — WWD Phase 1.0-1.2 live evidence + Phase 1.3-1.5+4.5 roadmap + 3 sibling separation 原則
7. Discussion — comparison vs Yahoo/Google/Smartnews/価格.com/食べログ/World Monitor + sustainability + replication argument + limitations + Pattern matrix
8. Related Work — Polis/Decidim/OpenForum + Catuṣkoṭi 形式化 literature + JP/EU/US legal precedent
9. Acceptance criteria for v0.1 (10 件)

**4 Appendix**: A timing rationale / B 3 sibling separation principle / C version history / D honest correction protocol.

**v0.1 publish gate** (10 criteria):
- Phase 1.0-1.2 完了 ✅ (本日 deploy)
- Phase 1.3 UI polish ⏸
- Phase 1.4 certification source + ToS verify ⏸
- **Phase 4.5 prototype voting cycle + 公開 audit log** ⏸ (核心 gate)
- 実 takedown response 1 例 ⏸
- 独立 legal review ⏸
- Pattern matrix audit clean ⏸
- 三者共著 consent + chat-Claude attribution finalized ⏸
- Zenodo + 11 platform publish path verified ⏸
- OctaTheoria Octet candidate 位置確定 ⏸

**Honest non-claims 5 件**:
1. ❌ "World-first 三層 architecture" (Polis/Decidim/OpenForum 既存)
2. ❌ "Lawsuit-proof" (lawsuit-PREVENTION, 撃ち落とせない設計でなく)
3. ❌ "Catuṣkoṭi-formalized" (Catuṣkoṭi-INSPIRED only, D-FUMT₈ 後 4 値は対応無し)
4. ❌ "Cross-jurisdiction validated" (JP のみ, US/EU framework 別)
5. ❌ "Currently operational L3 voting" (Phase 4.5 未実装)

**Pattern matrix self-audit (this OUTLINE)**: 6 軸全 clean / guarded.

## ★ 3 path 共通 — no-rush principle 順守

3 path 全て **v0.0 stage 維持**:
- Paper 154: scaffold smoke-run のみ / 実 evolved proof なし → v0.0
- Paper 26 v2: 単一 baseline のみ / numerical contrast なし → v0.0
- Paper 156: OUTLINE のみ / L3 voting 実装なし → v0.0

= 「急がず ゆっくりと」 + `feedback_no_rush_publication.md` operational 完全順守. 3 path とも publish-immediate に飛びつかず gate criteria を明示文書化.

## Pattern 累積 effect

Pattern 5 (existing-impl proposal 防止) self-aware action:
- B: 既存 alpha-evolve-engine.ts STEP 717 を**新提案でなく既存**として OpenEvolve scaffold で **正しく区別** (SCOPE.md per)
- C: 既存 `scripts/turboquant-phase1-baseline.ts` を発見 → 新規作成せず利用 (Pattern 5 防止 path-3-grep 順守)
- D: 既存 Paper 154 OUTLINE pattern を範例として再利用 (acceptance criteria + 4 Appendix + honest non-claims) → 設計 reuse, code reuse でない

= 累積 Pattern 5 += 3 (positive evidence as self-aware reuse).

## 関連 memory

- [[project_wwd_phase12_theory_dashboard_2026-05-22]] (WWD Phase 1.2 完了 = D の実装 evidence base)
- [[project_wwd_phase03_three_layer_2026-05-21]] (WWD 三層構造 + 9 原則 vision = D §3-§5 base)
- [[reference_secular_consciousness_treasure_2026]] (5/20 chat-Claude secular shift で referenced)
- Paper 154 OUTLINE template (papers/paper-154-compilation-pass-DRAFT.md, 本 OUTLINE format reuse base)

## Next session candidates

- Paper 26 v2: cross-model baseline (Goedel-Prover-V2:8b / DeepSeek-Prover-V2:7B / bfs-prover) で n=10 ずつ実測 + 比較表作成 → Phase 1 numerical contrast 強化
- Paper 154: OpenEvolve `pip install` user-gated 完了後 → 5-iteration smoke → 100-iteration full → evolved Lean proof generation
- Paper 156: WWD Phase 1.3-1.5 implementation + Phase 4.5 L3 voting prototype implementation (1-2 ヶ月 long-horizon)
- 5/22 invention (system 時刻 morning, invention pipeline 実行可能 — 別 turn)
- WWD Phase 1.3 UI polish (home page hero に category link card)