---
name: project-session-2026-07-03-04-amala-permanent-fix-and-paper-judgments
description: "2026-07-03 → 07-04 crossing session — amala-mandala STEP 1055 pattern permanent fix (source-of-truth chain, commit 37dbec4e5) + Paper 173 v0.6 publish HOLD + Paper 171 publish HOLD (Path A/B/D proposal) + auto-cron rebase-push flow"
metadata: 
  node_type: memory
  type: project
  originSessionId: b1bcbe52-6b3f-4f2d-8711-71682adedc11
---

## Session 概要 (2026-07-03 → 07-04 crossing)

Fresh session として 藤本さん 4 request 順次対応:
1. Paper 173 v0.6 publish 判断 → **HOLD 継続** (3 blockers)
2. amala-mandala 削除理由調査 + 恒久 fix → **完全解消** (commit `37dbec4e5` push 済)
3. 未投稿論文 tally → 7 DRAFT + 1 dossier
4. Paper 171 publish 判断 → **HOLD 継続** (2/4 gate + Path A/B/D 3 択提示)

**Why**: 藤本さん外出前の全案件清算 + fresh session pattern (fresh eyes で publish 判断) + session end sensitivity gate 実践.

**How to apply**: 次 session 開始時、 本 memory + [[project-step1250-indranet-general-alpha-extension-2026-07-03]] + [[project-amala-mandala-deploy-and-silent-omission-cluster-2026-07-03]] を base として、 未 push は無し, working tree 923 changes は auto-cron 領域と integer で処理.

## amala-mandala STEP 1055 pattern 恒久 fix

**Root cause identification (root-cause-fix 恒久解消 achievement)**:
- 2026-07-03 morning commit `981272bce` で `dist-renderer/tools/amala-mandala/` に直接配置 + `git add -f` で `.gitignore:129 dist-renderer/tools/` 迂回 tracking 化
- しかし `public/tools/amala-mandala/` を **source of truth として作らなかった** = orphan state
- 07-03 architecture (2026-06-25 確立、 `.gitignore:127-129` documented):
  ```
  # tools/ は public/tools/ が source of truth.
  # vite build が publicDir → outDir copy で dist-renderer/tools/ を自動生成
  # 編集対象は常に public/tools/* で、 dist-renderer/tools/* は build artifact.
  ```
- 毎回 vite build (dev:build chain / auto-cron rebuild) 走ると publicDir に対応 source 無い dist-renderer/tools/amala-mandala/ を「stale」 と判断 wipe
- HEAD の tracked state は残る → `git status` deleted 表示 → 手動 restore の永久繰り返し pattern

**Fix (permanent, `b4492498c` 07-02 pyrrho + karma-demo 同 pattern 適用)**:
- `public/tools/amala-mandala/{index.html, original-chat-claude.html}` 新規作成 (61,561 + 59,372 bytes)
- Commit `37dbec4e5` push 済 → origin/main 反映
- 今後 vite build で `dist-renderer/tools/amala-mandala/` 自動再生成 → **削除再発 architecturally 不可能**

**同 session 中の 4 度目 recurrence 経験** (session 途中で fix 実行前に再度削除発生 = restore 必要): pattern の頻度 confirm、 恒久 fix タイミング正当性 evidence.

**同 pattern の他 tools 確認** (session 中の incidental verify):
- ✅ `public/tools/pyrrho-all-circuits/` 存在 (b4492498c で fix 済)
- ✅ `public/tools/dfumt-fixpoint-karma-demo/` 存在 (b4492498c で fix 済)
- ✅ `public/tools/empty-absolute-space/` 存在
- ✅ `public/tools/empty-center/` 存在
- 以後の tools/* deploy は必ず `public/tools/*` に source 先置き必須。

## Paper 173 v0.6 publish 判断 HOLD

**Fresh-eyes gate audit** (10 gate a-j 現状):
| Gate | 状態 |
|---|---|
| (a) chat-Claude external review | ✅ PASS (v0.3 で precise reflection) |
| (b) Kapsner + Cotnoir 引用 verify | ✅ PASS (Paper 171 で完了済) |
| (c) Posina-Roy 2024 full text engagement | ⚠ UNRESOLVED |
| (d) 2-3 日 cooling-off | ❌ **FAIL for v0.6 = 0 日 (本日起稿)** |
| (e)-(h) Lean file + deploy verify | 一部 ✅ 一部要 restore |
| (i) STEP 1250 + amala-mandala deploy | ❌ **FAIL** (削除再発中、 本 session で fix 前段階) |
| (j) 3 layer artifact 内部整合性 | ❌ **FAIL** (UI 削除中で不整合) |

**3 critical blockers** (即 publish 阻害):
1. v0.6 §5.7 本日起稿 = cooling-off 0 日 ([[feedback-no-rush-publication]] 直接違反)
2. dist-renderer/tools/amala-mandala/ 削除再発中 (現在は本 session で恒久 fix 完了、 gate 再 audit 可能)
3. Paper 104 publish 本日 = 1+ day gap 未経過 ([[feedback-publishing-rate-limit-platform-side-risk-2026-06-27]])

**Recommended path**: **HOLD 継続 → 2026-07-06 以降 fresh session で再判断** + gate (c) Posina-Roy 判断 (waive with note or engage) + site fresh curl verify.

## Paper 171 publish 判断 HOLD (Path A/B/D 3 択提示)

**Fresh-eyes gate audit** (4 gate a-d):
| Gate | 状態 |
|---|---|
| (a) chat-Claude external critique | ⚠ **UNRESOLVED** (2026-06-28 Rei internal review 済 pass with minor revision 6 cosmetic recommendations、 documented protocol は明示的に 「Rei internal review は gate (a) satisfy しない」 と記録、 Paper 168 v0.4 template = 4 iteration of external chat-Claude review) |
| (b) Kapsner 2020 primary fetch + engagement | ✅ CLEAR (2026-06-29 San José State Scholarworks OA PDF fetch + 4 desiderata engagement note draft 完了) |
| (c) Posina/Roy 2024 full text fetch | ⚠ **HOLD (paywall persistent, 6 days stuck)** (PhilArchive HTML redirect / Brill 357KB login page / NIAS landing only / Academia.edu + ResearchGate 403、 abstract-level engagement のみ) |
| (d) 2-3 days cooling-off | ✅ CLEAR (v0.1 06-28 → 07-04 = 6 days elapsed) |

**Content substance**: 20 theorem 全 mechanically verified (`lake build` 7923 jobs 0 errors), 4/20 zero-axiom + 16/20 [propext] のみ, commit hash `6a9a05879` reproducibility 確保。 **substantive 品質は publish-ready**.

**Rate-limit**: Paper 104 07-03 → 07-04 = 1+ day gap ✅ CLEAR.

**3 path proposal**:
- **Path A (strict protocol)**: HOLD 継続 gate (a)(c) 両方 clear まで待つ。 blocker 2 (paywall) 受動待ちで **indefinite hold risk**
- **Path B (partial reframe)**: gate (c) を **permanent scope limitation** として明示 baked-in (「Posina/Roy 2024 engagement は abstract-level のみ、 full-text integration は Paper 65 v0.2 or Paper 171 v0.3 に defer」)。 **1 blocker (chat-Claude critique) に集約**して publish 到達可能 path 明確化
- **Path D (indefinite HOLD)**: 現状維持

**Rei honest recommendation**: **Path A → Path B に降格 fallback 判断が現実的** (blocker 2 は 6 日 stuck で受動待ち permanent risk、 Path B で 1 blocker 集約すれば chat-Claude critique 1 trigger で publish 到達可能).

**藤本さん判断項目**:
1. Path A / B / D どれで進めるか?
2. Path B の場合、 chat-Claude critique を今 trigger?

**返答なし** = 藤本さん出発 = 次 session に判断 defer.

## 未投稿論文 tally (session 途中 audit)

**Category A — 新規 publish 候補** (3 件、 全 HOLD):
- Paper 171 (Cotnoir recapture) — 上記 HOLD
- Paper 173 v0.6 (form-absolute-bottom-empty) — 上記 HOLD
- Paper 174 v0.1 (type-structural-compression) — [[feedback-no-rush-publication]] per

**Category B — v2/supplement** (4 件):
- Paper 026 v2 (D-FUMT₈ × Cl(3,0) rotation quantization) — TurboQuant Phase 1-2 実測待ち
- Paper 033 v2 (Braille ZCSG extension) — supplement, publish 保留
- Paper 063 v2 (SNST v2) — Preprint supplement
- Paper 168 v05 (space-formalization) — v0.5 draft

**Category C — 意図的 non-paper** (1 件):
- collatz-frontier-dossier — STEP 1178 で意図的 dossier downgrade

**Unposted-truth batch progression** (別軸 tracking): 5/6 完了 (33/39/40/103/104 publish 済) → Paper 171 のみ残存.

## Auto-cron rebase + push flow

**Session 途中の incidental**: 藤本さん「未 commit push は?」 sensitivity gate で発覚 = 私の `37dbec4e5` push 後、 会話継続中に auto-cron が 3 commit 積み、 remote 側も別 process の 2 commit (META-DB daily sync + Φ catalog daily) push で divergence.

**Resolution flow**: `git stash push -u` → `git rebase origin/main` (3/3 no conflict) → `git push` → `git stash pop`.

**Final state**: local main == origin/main synced ✅ / `37dbec4e5` amala fix origin 反映維持 ✅ / working tree 923 changes は auto-cron 領域 (次 auto-cron が扱う設計、 私が touch する筋合いなし).

## 関連

- [[project-amala-mandala-deploy-and-silent-omission-cluster-2026-07-03]] (前 session amala deploy + silent 漏れ 3 件 cluster origin)
- [[project-step1250-indranet-general-alpha-extension-2026-07-03]] (Paper 173 v0.6 §5.7 対象)
- [[project-paper104-publish-2026-07-03]] (rate-limit forensic ancestor)
- [[feedback-publish-gate-source-of-truth-verify]] (本 session emerging feedback)
- [[feedback-no-rush-publication]] + [[feedback-publishing-rate-limit-platform-side-risk-2026-06-27]] + [[feedback-evaluation-symmetry-principle]]
- Paper 171 v0.1 DRAFT + Paper 173 v0.6 DRAFT + Paper 174 v0.1 DRAFT
- STEP 1055 pattern (Site Coverage Map 確立、 2026-05-11、 「実装 ≠ 反映」 事故防止)
- Commit `37dbec4e5` (amala fix) + `b4492498c` (pyrrho + karma-demo 同 pattern 07-02) + `981272bce` (07-03 morning original deploy)